Celebrity Farewell: Alex McCord and Simon van Kempen List Historic Cobble Hill Townhouse for $2.695 Million
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn – A vibrant and storied neighborhood known for its tree-lined streets, historic brownstones, and tight-knit community, is preparing to bid adieu to two of its most recognizable residents. After nine years making their mark on this charming enclave, former “Real Housewives of New York City” stars Alex McCord and Simon van Kempen are embarking on a new chapter, listing their cherished townhouse at 56 Butler Street and preparing for a move to Australia to be closer to family. This news, confirmed by a spokeswoman for Stribling & Associates, the real estate firm managing the sale, marks a significant moment for fans and local real estate enthusiasts alike.
A Beloved Brownstone in a Prime Brooklyn Locale
The townhouse at 56 Butler Street isn’t just a property; it’s a piece of Cobble Hill’s rich tapestry and a home that has witnessed the public and private lives of a notable couple. Located in the heart of one of Brooklyn’s most desirable neighborhoods, this multi-family, six-bedroom residence offers a unique blend of historical grandeur and modern potential. Cobble Hill itself is a highly sought-after destination, celebrated for its picturesque blocks, distinguished architecture, and tranquil atmosphere, all while being just a stone’s throw from the bustling cultural hubs of Manhattan.
For prospective buyers seeking an authentic Brooklyn experience, Cobble Hill delivers on all fronts. Its streets are adorned with magnificent brownstones, Federal-style homes, and Greek Revival architecture, each telling a story of the borough’s past. The neighborhood boasts an array of independent boutiques, gourmet food shops, and highly acclaimed restaurants that cater to diverse tastes. Lush green spaces like Cobble Hill Park and Brooklyn Bridge Park are within easy reach, offering residents unparalleled recreational opportunities and breathtaking waterfront views. Excellent public and private schools make it a magnet for families, while convenient access to multiple subway lines ensures an effortless commute to any part of New York City.
Inside the McCord-van Kempen Residence: History and Character
Purchased by Alex and Simon in 2005 for $1,275,000, the property at 56 Butler Street now commands an asking price of $2,695,000. This substantial appreciation reflects not only the shrewd investment made by the couple but also the robust and continuously escalating value of real estate in Cobble Hill over the past decade. The house itself, configured as a three-family dwelling, presents a versatile layout, appealing to a wide range of buyers, from those seeking a spacious owner’s duplex with income-generating rental units to investors looking for a prime asset in a consistently high-performing market.
Spanning six generous bedrooms, the townhouse offers ample space for a large family or for reconfiguring into luxurious private suites and common areas. While the full extent of their renovations has been kept somewhat private, longtime readers and followers of the couple will recall snippets of their journey, including their insightful contributions as Brownstoner commenters and their attendance at local events. The house’s interior undoubtedly reflects the couple’s distinctive style and personality. One feature that has garnered particular attention and remains a memorable detail from their time in the spotlight is the living room, still painted in its famously controversial shade of red. This bold color choice, far from being a detractor, adds a layer of unique character and serves as a conversation starter, embodying the couple’s unapologetically vibrant approach to life and design. For a discerning buyer, this presents an opportunity to embrace a home with a story, or to envision their own personal touches within a solid, historic framework.
Architectural Highlights and Investment Potential
Typical of Cobble Hill brownstones, 56 Butler Street likely features a facade rich with architectural details – perhaps ornate cornices, decorative lintels, and classic stoops that invite a sense of grandeur and history. Inside, original details such as high ceilings, period moldings, and wide-plank hardwood floors may still grace the interiors, offering an authentic glimpse into the building’s past. Multi-family configurations, like this three-family setup, are highly desirable in Brooklyn for their flexibility. An owner can occupy a large portion of the home, such as a garden duplex or a triplex, while generating significant rental income from the remaining units, helping to offset mortgage costs. Alternatively, the layout provides options for guest quarters, home offices, or simply vast living spaces for a single expansive residence, subject to necessary conversions and permits.
The decision to sell comes at a time when the Brooklyn real estate market, especially for historical brownstones in prime neighborhoods like Cobble Hill, continues to show resilience and strong demand. Properties in this area are not merely homes; they are long-term investments that consistently appreciate in value, driven by limited inventory, a desirable lifestyle, and a thriving local economy. The McCord-van Kempen property, given its celebrity provenance and prime location, is expected to attract considerable interest from both local and international buyers seeking a slice of classic Brooklyn charm with a modern twist.
Alex and Simon: A Brooklyn Legacy and a New Horizon
Alex McCord and Simon van Kempen cemented their place in popular culture as key figures in “The Real Housewives of New York City,” bringing their unique dynamic and outspoken personalities to screens across the nation. Beyond the glare of reality television, they immersed themselves in the fabric of Brooklyn life, becoming familiar faces in the Cobble Hill community. Their renovation journey, often alluded to in discussions and local publications like Brownstoner, highlighted the passion and challenges inherent in restoring and personalizing a historic New York City brownstone. This project was more than just a house; it was a home they shaped and shared with their sons, Johan and Francois, within a community they grew to cherish.
Their active participation in local forums and events, as evidenced by Simon’s memorable presence as a Brownstoner commenter and their attendance at various neighborhood gatherings, underscored their genuine connection to Brooklyn. This engagement allowed them to become more than just celebrity residents; they were truly part of the Cobble Hill story, contributing to its vibrant dialogue and community spirit.
The decision to move to Australia, driven by the desire to be closer to family, represents a profound shift for the couple. It signifies a transition from their long-standing New York City life to a new chapter on another continent. While their presence will undoubtedly be missed in Cobble Hill, their move opens up an exciting opportunity for new owners to inherit a piece of Brooklyn history and continue the legacy of this remarkable home. This sale not only marks the end of an era for Alex and Simon in New York but also heralds a promising beginning for the next custodians of 56 Butler Street, inviting them to create their own memories within its storied walls.